2003-2004
The Stanford Alpine Journal is a yearly publication of the Stanford Alpine Club.
The Stanford Alpine Club has a distinguished history of alpine excellence. Its inspirations lie in the steep granite of the Yosemite Valley, but its members have contributed accomplishments around the globe. The SAC went dormant during the 1980s and 1990s, but was resurrected in 2002 to promote alpine pursuits in the Stanford Community.
The modem SAC perpetuates the original spirit of alpinism by providing a forum for planning excursions, and by introducing new members to the safe and responsible enjoyment of mountaineering, rock climbing, ice climbing, ski mountaineering, and other alpine pursuits.
Editor: Daniel Arnold
Layout and Design: Marshall Burke, John Montgomery-Brown, Bryan Palmintier,
Matt Farrell, and Daniel Arnold
Copyright 2004
No Portion of this Journal may be reproduced without permission of the
Stanford Alpine Club.
Letters to the Editor and submissions to the journal should be sent to:
Stanford Alpine Journal
PO Box 571
Palo Alto, CA 94302
Cover Photo: Tom Frost (BS '58), Dihedral Wall, 1964. Photo by Royal Robbins and courtesy of Tom Frost. Special thanks to Tom Frost for the use of his photographs in this year's Journal.
Letter from the Editor
By Daniel Arnold.............................................Pg 3
Irene's Arete, Again
By Irene Beardsley...........................................Pg 6
Who Says Frontcountry Isn't Adventurous?
By Dave Weaver.............................................Pg 15
An Accident on Temple Crag
By Polly Fordyce.............................................Pg 21
The Mountain Room Lounge
By Daniel Arnold.............................................Pg 26
Ascents and Adventures..................................Pg 31
Polly Fordyce, Cinnamon Slab, Smith Rock, OR.
  Photo by Marshall Burke.
The Death of Adventure
Go to Mt. Everest. Gobble down your acetozolamide, while your porters carry
your gear to base camp. Rummage through your day pack and decide whether
you'll eat a sandwich or call up your buddy on your handheld talkabout (love
that little Beep-BOOP-it just fits, you know?). When you hit the snow, turn
on the heating elements in your socks and in yourjacket. Check the satellite
uplink on your computer (the porters carried it in for you) for the latest
weather report. Bust out a few emails and update your blog. Then grab your
oxygen tank (love those porters!), turn the O's up high, and don't bother
looking to the west, just keep your head down. If the weather craps out, your
basecamp team will let you know on your radio and you can call for a rescue on
your sat-phone.
But don't tell me you've climbed Mt. E. Not here. Not interested.
Here's the painful truth: we humans have hit the spot on the technological
curve where the competition between ourselves and the environment is no longer
equal. Anyone can climb new rock on El Cap with a Bosch drill and a loose
sense of moral propriety (why don't you just rap down on a three-thousand foot
line and chisel out a 28-pitch hand crack, for chrissake). Technology can
take the bite out of El Cap, and technology is doing its damnedest to turn
Everest into a glorified Stair Master.
I can already hear the whining. But we don't want to climb with rules.
We want freedom! We want to frolic through the mountains, filling the empty
air with the Beeps and Boops of our talkabouts!
The whole point of outdoor adventure sports is the sense of uncertainty that an
uncontrolled environment contains. Remove that uncertainty and all you have
left is a mechanical connect the topo dots problem. I can already see the day
when Garmin will sell the "Sierra Approach" package for your handheld GPS.
BEEP-boop: "Turn ten degrees west ... now. Walk zero-point-four miles."
BEEP-boop: "Turn fifteen degrees north ... now. Walk zero-point-seven miles
to the base of Mt. Ritter." Just stare at the little arrow on your LCD display
and follow it like a trained donkey. Why don't you just stay home and play a
video game?
This is why the style of any given climb has become such a hot topic in recent
years. More and more climbers are realizing that the technology game has an
endpoint, where every fat novice can haul himself up Everest given sufficient
drugs, machines, oxygen tanks, guides, and porters. We have reached an
unfortunate time when not all ascents are equal. The overuse of technology
can eliminate so many of the mental and physical difficulties that make climbing
unique and separate from the easy living of modem society.
So what's a climber bombarded with REI catalogues and Everest summit blogs to
do? Get rid of the machines! If it runs on batteries, if it makes artificial
noises, if it means that you can rely on it instead of your brain or your
training, chances are you can do without it.
Why do I climb? I climb to test my abilities to cope in a wild, demanding,
beautiful landscape. It's a self-imposed test. If I use artificial aids to
cheat, I have only cheated myself and cheapened my own experience. Mechanical
aids only reduce that sense of wildness and beauty, and take away from the
sense of satisfaction that comes from having succeeded based on skill, rather
than on the protective layers of gear and detritus that we build up between
ourselves and the mountains.
Why do I care? I care because the stories matter. Half the pleasure of
climbing is relaxing with a group of friends and telling some wild tales.
But I don't want to listen to people describing their journeys through the
electronic GPS jungles, or about summit phone calls from the top of Mt. Whitney,
or how they had to put in those bolts because "there was no other way to do
the climb." I want to hear about success that was earned through skill and
self-reliance, and about the use of wit rather than technology. These are the
climbs that count for something and make the storyteller proud.
The history of climbing and mountaineering is filled with good stories, and I
worry that the current generation of climbers is losing track of its roots.
The modem climber can do nothing more valuable than to look at the minimalism
of mountaineering's past in order to assess what is truly "necessary"
equipment for a climb. The answer, of course, is that it's in the head, not
the hardware.
-Daniel Arnold, December 2004.
By Irene Beardsley
Having a classic climb named for oneself can be a matter of luck and being in
the right place at the right time. In fact, Irene's Arete is something of a
problem for me in conversation, particularly since I did no leading on the
first ascent, or indeed on three subsequent ascents, and yet I've always been
proud of that first one. Anyway, there we were at the Jenny Lake campground
in the Tetons in the summer of 1957. My husband, Leigh Ortenburger, had gotten
out of the army a little early to take up "seasonal employment" with the
Petzoldt-Exum Guide Service. We had met while I was learning to climb with
the Stanford Alpine Club in 1953.
I visited the Tetons for the first time in 1955. Leigh was on his way from
basic training in the US Army to an assignment in Maryland. On that occasion
we climbed the Grand Teton by connecting Okie's Thom, a southern traverse of
the Molar Tooth, and the East Ridge. Then he went on to the east coast and I
returned to Stanford for my junior year. After our marriage in 1956, I spent
the summer living in a muggy apartment in Maryland and working for the Bureau of
Standards, while Leigh got away from the army for a month to go as a guide on a
Sierra Club trip led by Al and Gail Baxter to the northern St. Elias Range.
This year, 1957, we spent a few days in the north end of the range, and then
Leigh guided a trip for Exum, in which I was not allowed to participate.
He wound up with Achilles tendonitis, and I was restless. The solution: Leigh
took me to the campsite of John Dietschy and said, "John, this is my wife, why
don't you take her climbing?" John was a medical student from Washington
University, about to enter his last year. Leigh had corresponded with him in
his researches for the guidebook. John said "Okay," and several days later we
packed up to the Petzoldt Caves with three days of food.
We spent the first day on leisurely ascents of Fairshare Tower and its
subpinnacle, the Watchtower, right above the caves. Pemmican Pillar and
Fairshare Tower, located on the ridge connecting the Grand Teton and
Disappointment Peak, mark an earlier SAC escapade. Leigh, Dick Irvin,
Nick Clinch, and John Mowat were returning along the Black Dike the next day
after climbing the East Ridge in 1951. Leigh spotted the possibly unclimbed
pinnacles and asked Nick to open his emergency can of pemmican. When it was
passed around, Leigh said he might take a small bite, whereupon Nick,
realizing what was up, said, "Hell, no, you'll eat your fair share!" Leigh
and Dick went off to bag new routes, left the can as a summit register, and
named the pinnacles.
This long, easy day gave John and me a chance to get used to climbing together.
That night John spent some time after dinner sitting on top of the rock above
the caves, smoking his pipe and looking at the proposed route for the next day.
It didn't look that promising to me. The arete in question was a nearly
vertical knife-edge, with two steps and a final notch before finally leveling
out to the plateau of Disappointment.
The next morning we traversed several steep gulleys over to the base of the
arete. The first pitch was already more challenging than any of the climbing
I had done as a Stanford Alpine Club member in Yosemite or on the East Ridge
of the Grand the year before. We were both wearing leather climbing boots
with Vibram soles. Mine were boots my mother had worn on fishing trips that
had been resoled. The rope was 7/16" nylon, 120 feet long. We would have tied
in with a bowline on a coil, since climbing harnesses had not appeared. This
being the era of pitons, I had to spend considerable time and effort removing
them. I remember anxious belaying, sending up the pack, and piton removal.
John made it easier for me by using a haul line for the pack on every pitch.
The features of the climb that stand out now, besides the general steepness and
exposure, are the crux, a difficult 5.8 move to the left at the beginning of
the fourth pitch, and the small white crystal that I had to stand on over an
overhang on the right side of the ridge later on the same pitch. I'm sure I
used a tight rope for a few feet on the crux, and I know I used tension while
removing some of the pitons.
We kept making progress, and finally reached the prominent notch at the top of
what is now the fifth pitch just below the difficult 5.9+ face. I think we
took seven pitches to get there with the 120-foot rope. There was an
electrical storm coming, and we took shelter to the right of the ridge under
an overhang while the skies opened up. I had tried hard during the climb to
act as if this whole thing were no big deal, but I had a brief crying fit
under the overhang, which I attributed to overexposure. When the storm ended,
there was no thought of going up the easier rock to the top of the arete, and
we descended by climbing off to the right and down a gully, with several
rappels. The gully was not a particularly nice place, but it worked. Back at
the caves, in a jubilant mood, we were greeted by some of John's friends who
had come up to climb the Exum Ridge with us.
On the following day John gave me the treat of leading the party up the Exum
Ridge, making all the route-finding decisions. It was a thrill to lead it on
my first ascent, based on my reading of the guidebook, and to climb the
Friction Pitch and then say, "Oh, that must have been it." Then we descended
to the valley, and John disappeared off to his last year of medical school
and a great career. I was very surprised some months later to learn that he
had used the privilege of the first ascender to name the arete for me.
The climb went on to become extremely popular.
Quoting the guidebook: "This outstanding rock climb of a beautiful knife-edge
ridge has become one of the most popular of the difficult rock climbs in the
Tetons. Purity of line, excellence of rock, and ease of access contribute to
its high regard."
During my years in graduate school I continued to climb actively in the summers.
As an undergraduate in the club I had not led, nor had I been encouraged to,
but now I started to do some easier leading. We went on expeditions to Peru in
1958 and 1964, and Leigh was on an expedition to Makalu in 1961, during which I
walked to and from the Everest region and spent three weeks at 19,000 ft.
I enjoyed altitude and started to think I could climb a really high mountain if
I got the chance. Needless to say, all this summer climbing retarded my
progress through graduate school.
Climbing paused in 1966, when after the birth of my second daughter a nagging
back problem turned serious and I had to quit climbing and running. After a
two-level spinal fusion in 1967 there was a gap of several years, and when I
started to climb again, it was at a much lower level, and for the first few
years I wore a back brace. Eventually I was able to throw away the brace and
started to be able to run again, longer distances and not as fast. We did more
summer climbing in the Tetons, even some of moderate difficulty, but after the
back surgery I felt like I didn't ever want to fall even three feet, and I did
much less leading.
Twice I had the opportunity to go back up Irene's Arete with some good friends
who were members of the outstanding group of Jenny Lake Seasonal Rangers.
In 1981 I used rock shoes instead of boots, and with no pitons to remove the
twenty-four years did not seem to matter. The climb was exhilarating, the crux
move was still difficult for me, but the company of Renny Jackson, Bob Irvine,
and Chris Anderson was delightful. Coming back to the caves, Bob told some
other climbers, "We just climbed Irene's Arete; guess who this is!" The next
time in 1984 was with Bob again and Rich Perch. When they had me climb the
alternate 5.9 flaring open book near the top. I was able to stem up high
enough to get my hands on the top edge, at which point my strength gave out and
I had to be hauled up like a sack of potatoes over the rim. I was happy, and
at the same time pretty sure that would be the last time up the climb for me.
In 1986 Dan Bloomberg and I were married. He was not a rock climber, and we
settled into a routine of killer hikes, 3rd-class scrambles, and peaks that we
could do in a day without a rope. This continued until Dave Carman, a wily
old Exum guide, began spending winters in our house in Jackson Hole. He and I
started making one or two roped climbs each summer. I got to remember what it
was like to have a rope on, and we tried to find appropriate climbs that
interested me and would not bore him.
The second year we climbed together we did the South Buttress on Mt. Moran,
which was probably reaching too far. My direct aid skills were minimal and
unrehearsed. Dave has still probably not forgiven me for the fact that we
bivouacked, a first for him in many years as a guide. On the other hand, I
had never dared think of doing that climb even during the time when I was
climbing well, and it was definitely a thrill to see those famous pitches that
Leigh had been involved in on the first ascent. After that we were more careful
in our route selection and managed some satisfying ascents. We developed a
system in which I would approach the climb the day before and camp, and Dave
would hike up in the morning. In just that manner we did the East Ridge of
the Grand, sleeping below the Molar Tooth and carrying our bivy gear over the
top. In 2003 we were completely skunked by the weather. I had wanted to climb
the East Ridge of Disappointment, because I had turned around just below the
crux in 1982, but it snowed that day. I was sleeping at Amphitheatre Lake and
Dave arrived the next morning in the middle of the snowstorm, so we just
retreated down the trail.
This past spring I started to have chronic back pain, no doubt related to the
earlier surgery and years of stress on the joint above the fusion. Renny, the
Jenny Lake Area Ranger since 1991, had promised to take me on a 50th-anniversary
climb of the Grand in 2005. After Leigh's death, I had helped Renny finish the
revision of the 3rd edition of "A Climber's Guide to the Teton Range." This past
summer I told him that maybe we had better make it a 49th anniversary instead.
He agreed that we would do "something" this summer, and Dave said he would like
to join us. Those two are good friends but usually never see each other in the
course of a busy summer, unless we invite them both to dinner.
As the end of the summer approached, somehow the goal changed. Dave and Renny
started promoting the arete instead of the Grand. This sounded like a really
bad idea to me, since I hadn't done a rock climb in two years and thought I
would never go there again, but it would definitely be less boring for them,
and with friends like this, what choice did I have? Dave told me to work on
assisted pullups. There is a pullup system hanging from the rafters in the
living room of our house in Jackson Hole that was put up years ago for Dave's
son, Adam, and somehow never had been taken down. So several times a day I
did as many as I could.
Dan and I went to the Wind Rivers with a large group of overage friends, using
horses to carry most of the weight in and out. We had a week of perfect
weather and a great time peakbagging. I came back stronger but with some new
overuse aches and pains; fortunately the weather turned really bad for a week
while I worked on recovery. When everyone was free and it looked like there
was a window of settled weather, Dan helped by carrying my overnight gear up
to Lupine Meadows. I had a book to read, but it was more distracting to chat
with other climbers camped all around. I had no stove, but I had a teabag,
and scrounged some hot water from a nice couple from Georgia. In the morning,
I took my climbing gear and strolled up to the Petzoldt Caves, changed into
rock shoes (the same ones from 1984), and took some pain pills. The weather
did not look good, and I was sitting there full of misgivings. Renny and Dave
arrived in half an hour, and Renny said, "Well, why don't we just go over to
the bottom of the climb and see what happens?" When got there we figured we
could go up at least a couple of pitches and still retreat if necessary.
We started out with Renny leading. I had thought I would be tied into the
middle, as on the last two times, but no, Renny said he would belay both of us
at once. I trusted Renny's rescue expertise and didn't look too closely at
the belaying arrangement. The first pitch is immediately 5.7, just to the
right of the knife-edge ridge crest. Dave was climbing right behind me and he
could see the worried look on my face and hear my mutterings. I was telling
myself that if I lived through this, I would never have to put myself through
a similar experience.
Fortunately or not, I couldn't remember where the crux was. Meanwhile Dave was
enjoying the rare experience for him of following on nice rock. The weather
was not getting worse, in fact was actually getting better. The sun came out.
This climb is blessed with some of the most beautiful rock in the Tetons; even
on the first ascent there was no loose rock. Periodically Renny would ask me
to stop for a photographic opportunity. Soon enough we were at the top of the
third pitch, right up against the 5.8 crux of the regular route. Renny and Dave
switched leads, and Dave easily made the difficult move out to the left of the
crest and stopped in a black rock area not that far above. As in every
previous ascent, I couldn't quite pull this off without a tight rope for a few
feet. Now I had Renny climbing closely behind me, occasionally pulling ahead
to take another photo.
Once past the crux, I started to enjoy the day, the company, and the climbing.
The fifth pitch began out to the right with the step onto the white crystal
that I remembered so well, but it was not so difficult, followed by what Dave
referred to as a gnarly crack with poor protection. At the fifth belay we
were just below the 5.9 open book, but we avoided that and went around to the
left of the ridge. It didn't seem as hard as the 5.7 rating in the guidebook.
Dave tells me that I had a smile on my face on the entire second half of the
climb. I was definitely wishing that it wouldn't end.
We took a welcome break for lunch, then finished the easy fourth class to the
summit plateau and made our way west over to the descent gully. Once we were
down that, we were almost back to the caves. There Renny took off, as he
needed to catch up with his daughter, and Dave and I picked up my sleeping
gear in the Garnet Canyon Meadows and made our way back down to the car. Dan
was there to meet us, and we went back to Dave's cabin to sort gear and relax.
What a personal high! Thank you, Renny and Dave. I was honored by the fact
that my friends thought I could do it, no sweat, at age 69 and hardly climbing
anymore, and that they wanted to be the ones to make it a reality for me.
I was surprised that all went as well as it did.
And now, what goal for 2005? The Grand Teton, of course.
-Irene Beardsley has Stanford degrees in Physics from 1957, '58, and '65.
She treasures her summers in the Tetons, and still tries to do one roped climb
every year. She is the keeper of the alumni list for the original SAC.
PHOTOGRAPHS:
1) Irene's Arete; Renny Jackson
2) Irene on first ascent of eponymous arete, 1957; John Dietschy
3) and 4) Irene on 2004 ascent; Renny Jackson.
By David Weaver
"Of course I can make it up on Tuesday. There's going to be nine feet of snow!"
So Phil and I meet up one hour later and begin our drive to The Wood, aka
Kirkwood. About 24 hours later, we are glowing from our incredible day of
freshies. Visibility was zero, but there was nobody at the mountain. Totally
epic. Now you see, that's about all I'm going to mention about how awesome
the skiing was for the entire story. Not that the skiing wasn't incredible, or
the deepest most bottomless snow ever (because it was), it's just that there
were more adventures to be had than just on the slope. And if you are my mom
or my boss, this story is, of course, pure fiction. Maybe.
So anyway, Phil and I are drinking at Bub's sports bar at Kirkwood. The beer
makes the soreness in the legs much better. We made friends with this guy
Jack at the bar and bought him a few beers, you know, to be nice. When it was
his turn for a round, he said that he had some bud in his truck.
"Sure," we said. "Budweiser sounds good."
We get to the car, and from the drivers seat he pulls out a two-foot-long bong.
"Oh-you meant bud. Not Budweiser. That's cool."
So at this point, Phil and I are not at peak mental capacity. And it's cold.
And snowing really hard. And then a little demon-weasel pokes its black-eyed
face out from the innards of Jack's soul.
"Good God-an alien!" I yell.
"No, man. That's just Princess. She's my Chihuahua. She's from Mexico, you
know? She don't like the cold too much so I gotta keep her in my jacket. But
she likes the snow. Check this out."
Jack takes Princess out of his jacket and holds her over his shoulder like a
dinner platter. Then he launches her about ten feet up and into the snow
bank. Princess tunnels her way under the snow and polks her demon-face out
and Jack throws her shivering little frame back into his jacket.
"That's horrible. I can't believe you just did that," I say.
"Yeah, I know," Jack says as he looks down at his feet. "You wanna try?"
"Hell yeah."
So I take Princess and launch her into the snow bank.
"What time do I get kicked out of here?" I ask.
"About ten o'clock"
"Cool. Thanks. Do you know a place where I could dig a snow pit, but not have
to worry about getting run over by a snow-cat in the middle of the night?"
"What the hell are you talking about?"
"You know. I'm going to sleep in a snow cave."
"Are you crazy? You ain't gunna sleep out there. It's going to snow three
feet tonight. If you buy me and my friends some beer, you can stay with us.
We live in Animal House - the employee housing."
"Sounds good to me."
So I bought a 12 pack of PBR for Sam to bring over as rent. He was psyched.
PBR was his favorite.
"So, do you ski or snowboard?"
"Well, I telemark ski."
"Ah, I get it. You're one of those hippies. That's why you were going to
sleep outside."
"Um, yeah. I guess."
"That's pretty cool though. Hey, thanks for the beer. You want a cigarette?
Oh - wait - you tele ski. Those guys never smoke cigarettes."
So we were doing the usual as we drank the PBR. You know - watching the
Ultimate Fighting Championship 'Greatest Hits' video. Inviting over Sam's
professional juggler friend so he could juggle eggs, a gallon of paint, and a
5-pound sack of flour. And then dropping the five-pound sack of flour. And
then dropping the gallon of paint on the five-pound sack of flour. Sam got
kind of mad about the flour and paint on the floor though. So he threw a
handful of the flour in the juggler's eyes. Then the juggler got a knife and
chased Sam around for about half hour trying to stab him. I guess he never
caught him because when I woke up the next day he was still alive.
And then yet another epic day of bottomless powder. I finished out the
weekend in style with my friends and just went home.
We were eating lunch at Red Cliffs when we saw smoke billowing up from behind
the lodge. We checked it out-the power plant of Kirkwood was on fire. Huge
flames. Thick smoke. No more skiing that day.
Unfortunately, we couldn't leave the resort because the fire trucks were
blocking the entrance. So what happens when you get a bunch of people stuck
in the snow? You start throwing snowballs, of course.
There was a swarm of about twenty high school kids up on this knoll raining
snowballs down on us, and we were doing our best to throw back, but they had
better positioning. We decided to act. Jeff, Chris, and I put on our helmets
and goggles and made a bold charge up the hill. We got better position and
began throwing from closer range. Our surprise attack worked, the high school
kids were flustered. Chris, the random guy that we met on the email list,
decided to charge ahead further. Escalation. Within minutes, Chris ended up
on his back with a crazy kid trying to claw his eyes out and the other nineteen
of the little truants pulling Jeff and I down. By the time ski patrol broke it
all up, Chris had scratches on his cheeks, forehead, and nose from the kid's
fingernails.
Anyway, we finally got out of there and began our drive home. Chris and Jeff
were with Jared in the first car, and I was in the second car with Ross and
Angela. We were about halfway back to Stanford when Ross, the driver, swerved
in the middle of the highway.
"Snowboard!" he yelled. "I just had to dodge a snowboard at like seventy
miles an hour!"
Then we saw Jared, the driver of the first car, running down the shoulder of
the highway against traffic. A few seconds later we passed Jared's car.
Jeff and Chris were standing next to the car shaking their heads.
I gave Jeff a call on my phone and asked him what had happened.
"Apparently, Jared's roof rack isn't strong enough for snowboards," Jeff told
me. It opened and Chris, the guy who was just in the fight, had his snowboard
fall off. Jared could see it floating like a feather down toward the highway
in his rearview mirror. Unfortunately the white minivan that was directly
behind us couldn't dodge it and totaled the board. "It's dead," Jeff said.
"No more snow for that one."
We got the rest of the way home without incident. So now I think I'm going to
focus a bit more on my backcountry skiing, because it seems to be a little
more predictable and a bit less adventurous.
-Dave Weaver will be getting his Chem E PhD in August, and claims that he is
"too hosed" to do much climbing in the near future, though we don't believe him.
PHOTOGRAPHS: 1) Edward Boenig 2) Chris Barrington-Leigh 3) Brett Parker.
By Polly Fordyce and Ren Buckley
Ren Buckley, Matt Lappe, Marshall Burke, and I (PMF) headed down to Temple Crag
over the last weekend of August in 2003 to do some alpine climbing. The plan
was to hike in on Saturday, set up camp at Third Lake, and then climb either
Venusian Blind or the Moon Goddess Arete on Sunday. Ren and I planned to hike
out and drive home Monday, leaving Matt and Marshall to climb some more.
On Sunday morning, we woke up to discover that one of the ropes had been left
in the car. We decided that Ren and I would start climbing while Marshall ran
down to the car to get the second rope, and then Matt and Marshall would
continue up and meet us after Marshall got back. Despite initially ensuring
that both climbing parties had knives, we were not to realize until we needed
one that the unexpected partner switch left Ren and I knifeless.
We hiked up to the base of Moon Goddess Arete (about an hour from camp) and
found that the approach to the usual start, as well as the first ten feet of
the route, were covered in snow, so we decided to climb the alternate start.
To get to the alternate start, we had to first scramble up several fourth
class ledges. The first pitches of Moon Goddess are mostly fourth class with a
single 5.6 move at the start. Ren and I decided to rope up for the move.
The belay ledge was approximately six feet wide with a fourth class cliff below.
We built an anchor, consisting of two pieces of protection equalized with a
20ft cordelette, in a crack several feet to climber's right of the route.
I took the lead on the first pitch, and about ten feet up I dislodged a large
boulder that probably weighed about 300 pounds and was three to four feet tall.
Ren believes that the bottom of the boulder hit the ground to climber's left of
the belay. The top of the boulder then keeled over, hitting her face and
landing on the anchor cordelette. Ren was knocked down and found herself on
her left side under the boulder with her feet propped against the wall.
The weight of the boulder on the cordelette placed pressure on her harness and
prevented full circulation to her legs. The boulder itself applied additional
pressure to her hips and the left side of her ribs. Her upper body was free.
The boulder was fairly stable, but releasing the cordelette and harness system
would have resulted in the rock falling on and potentially crushing her lower
body. A second, smaller boulder was wedged at her back and was eventually
cleared.
The boulder was wedged in between the sides of the belay ledge and could not be
rolled off to either side. Ren was still conscious, so the two of us talked
through the viable options. I first set up an independent anchor so that Ren
would be attached to the wall with a chest harness in case the belay anchor
and the boulder released. We decided that I should try to rig up a pulley
system with the free rope to raise the rock up.
I tried to set up an anchor above the boulder, attach part of the rope to the
anchor and then wrap a portion of the rope around the boulder and back up to a
biner at the anchor to create a 3:1 advantage to help me lift the boulder up.
The rope was pinned in many places, and it was hard to find a long enough
section of free rope to wrap around the boulder, through the anchor, and pull.
It would have been really helpful to have a knife to free parts of the rope
for this. I tried this for some time, but couldn't pull with enough force to
lift the boulder. The weight of the boulder pulling on Ren's harness was
growing more painful and her hips and left leg had started to lose feeling.
We then decided that I should run down to try to find Marshall and Matt and
bring them back to help move the rock. Although I realized that leaving was
the most effective way for me to help her, it was still very difficult for me
to just leave her there. It felt like I was failing her, and I couldn't think
of anything to do differently.
I ran almost all the way down to Third Lake, where Marshall and Matt heard me
yelling, and came out to meet me. Marshall went back to camp to bring
splinting materials and things that we could use to carry Ren out, and Matt
and I ran back up to the accident site. On the way, we were incredibly
fortunate to meet up with two YOSAR personnel, Janet and Phil, who were on
their way up to do a ridge traverse starting with the Venusian Blind route.
Janet and Phil were clearly very experienced with this sort of rescue, and
their presence was reassuring. They had a textbook way of handling the
situation; they were very calm and asked questions slowly, as if to reassure
me that this sort of thing happened all the time and would turn out all right.
Phil, Janet, Matt, and I climbed up to the ledge where Ren was trapped.
Janet, a nurse, assessed Ren's condition and circulation, and Phil had a knife
with him and was able to free most of the rope.
He built an additional anchor and rigged a 2:1 pulley system. The rescue
involved three anchors: the initial belay anchor held the boulder; a second
anchored secured Ren and the rescuers to the ledge; and the third held the
pulley system. With Matt lifting and Phil cranking on the pulley system, the
boulder was raised up. A Petzl Tibloc provided an efficient way to lock off
the pulley system so that the belay anchor cordelette could be cut and Ren
pulled out from under the rock by Janet. Ren was initially shaking
considerably due to a likely combination of shock and hypothermia. Phil cut
the pulley system to release the boulder, which slid off the ledge and broke
into a number of pieces upon landing at the base of the cliff. A fireman
belay was rigged to get Ren off the ledge and into the sunshine.
Ren was able to walk eventually, so she and I walked out to the car. Ren was
moving somewhat slowly, but overall, she felt remarkably good. We were so
elated at the fact that she was moving around that we treated ourselves to
gelato and hot springs rather than a hospital visit. We then started driving
back to Stanford and camped out at Tuolumne. The next morning, she woke up
with numbness at the surface of both of her thighs. She suffered nerve damage
in her legs so that they felt numb for several months, but the feeling
eventually returned to them. She also suffered an injury to her ACL and knee
cartilage during the accident, and later had to have surgery.
Ren was an incredibly brave and calm victim, and she deserves a lot of credit
for helping with her own rescue by talking through a lot of the options with
me and helping me to make decisions. I've gone over the accident a lot in my
head to try to think of how I could have prevented it. I wish that I had
checked the stability of the boulder more thoroughly before I weighted it.
I now try to carry a knife with me whenever I climb, in case there is ever
another situation where I need to cut the rope during a rescue. Alpine
climbing with another party seems like a good idea, and walkie talkies to
communicate between parties could greatly facilitate rescue efforts. I would
also stress to other climbers that the routes on Temple Crag are loose,
committing, longer, and more remote than climbs of similar difficulty in
Tuolumne.
PHOTOGRAPHS:
1) Polly Fordyce in the Sierra backcountry; Marshall Burke.
2) Third Lake from the snowpatches below Moongoddess Arete near the accident
site; Matt Farrell.
3) Temple Crag looming over Third Lake; Matt Farrell.
A Letter From the Editor
Tom Frost, The Nose, 1997.
  Photo by Ryan Frost.
Royal Robbins and TM Herbert, Camp 4.
  Photo by Tom Frost.
Irene's Arete, Again




Backcountry skiing, southern Sierra Nevada.
  Photo by Marshall Burke.
Chris Higgins and John Montgomery-Brown, Pinnacles, CA.
  Photo by Emily Desmarais.
Who Says the Front Country isn't Adventurous?

Phil and I wake up the next day in his truck. Everything hurts. Time to hit
the slopes again. At the end of the day, Phil says he has to leave because he
has this obligation that he refers to as 'a wife.' So I take my sleeping bag,
tarp, and shovel, and wave goodbye to my ride. I figure I can just dig a snow
pit and bivy there for the night. Then my other friends are coming up on
Saturday and Sunday to ski, so I can stay with them on Saturday and go home
with them on Sunday. I had a plan. But as always, my plan changed. In the
lodge, I met up with some 19-year-old kid that cleans the lodge up at the end
of the day.
And then almost exactly one year later, we decide to head up to The Wood with
some random people from the new skiing email list. It was all good, about
two-thirds of us were the normal and the other few were new. It was all going
fine until about noon that day when Kirkwood caught on fire.


Matt Lappe, East Buttress of El Capitan, Yosemite.
  Photo by Marshall Burke.
A snowy day in Joshua Tree National Park.
  Photo by John Montgomery-Brown.
An Accident on Temple Crag



Ryan Frost at the beginning of The Narrows, Steck-Salathe, Yosemite.
  Photo by Tom Frost.